IT support options compared

Who should look after your IT?

There are six realistic ways for a small business to handle IT. Each is the right answer for someone. This table shows where we are strong, where we are not, and when one of the other options is the better choice.

StrongPartlyWeak
CriterionVantage 365 SupportMicrosoft specialistLocal generalist IT companyNational managed service providerFreelance IT contractorIn-house IT personDoing it yourself
Deep Microsoft 365 expertise
Strong

Microsoft is our specialism. Identity, Intune, Defender and licensing are what we work on every day.

Partly

Usually strong on hardware and networks. Microsoft 365 is one of many things they cover.

Partly

The specialists exist, but you may not reach them through the first-line helpdesk.

Partly

Depends entirely on the individual you find.

Partly

One person rarely has depth across every part of Microsoft 365.

Weak

You learn as you go, usually after something has gone wrong.

One published price, licence included
Strong

£79 per user per month, with Microsoft 365 Business Premium included. Prices exclude VAT.

Weak

Prices are rarely published, and Microsoft licences are usually billed on top of the support fee.

Weak

Bespoke quotes, with licences and add-ons itemised separately.

Partly

The day rate is clear, but the total depends on how much goes wrong.

Weak

Salary, National Insurance, pension, training and tools, plus the licences.

Partly

You pay Microsoft directly. The hidden cost is your own time.

Lowest monthly cost
Partly

We are not the cheapest seat price. Because the licence is included, compare totals, not headline numbers.

Partly

Often cheaper on the headline seat price, before licences are added.

Partly

Can be competitive at scale, less so for small teams.

Strong

Cheapest in a month when nothing goes wrong.

Weak

A full-time salary costs more than managed support until you are much larger.

Strong

No support bill, as long as your time costs nothing.

Helpdesk answered during the working day
Strong

Unlimited helpdesk, Monday to Friday, 8am to 6pm, answered by the people who fix the problem.

Strong

Normally yes, during office hours.

Strong

A large helpdesk with agreed service levels.

Weak

If they are on another job, you wait.

Partly

Immediate, unless they are off, busy or in a meeting.

Weak

There is no helpdesk. There is a search engine.

24/7 monitoring and out-of-hours cover
Weak

We cover working days only, and review security alerts every working day. If you genuinely need 24/7 cover, we will tell you and help you find it.

Partly

Some offer out-of-hours cover, usually at extra cost.

Strong

Often include a 24/7 service desk or security operations centre.

Weak

One person cannot be on call all the time.

Weak

Out of hours means waiting until the morning.

Weak

Nobody is watching.

Someone on site when it is needed
Partly

Within about half an hour of our Brierley Hill office. Further out, support is remote.

Strong

A local engineer can usually get to you.

Partly

Often subcontracted, or charged as an extra.

Strong

Usually happy to come out, if they are free.

Strong

Already in the building.

Partly

You are already there. You just have to fix it yourself.

Security and compliance you can evidence
Strong

We hold Cyber Essentials Plus ourselves, and configure and document the controls for you.

Partly

Varies widely. Ask whether they hold Cyber Essentials Plus themselves.

Strong

Formal processes, certifications and audit trails.

Weak

Rarely documented or independently checked.

Partly

Depends on their skills and how much time they get for it.

Weak

Hard to evidence what you have never had checked.

Cover for holidays and sickness
Strong

A team, so someone always picks up.

Strong

A team, so someone always picks up.

Strong

A large team with rotas.

Weak

When they are away, so is your support.

Weak

When they are off, so is your IT.

Weak

When you are away, nobody covers.

Knows your business and your people
Strong

A small local team that already knows your tenant when you call.

Strong

Smaller local firms usually get to know their clients well.

Weak

Large queues and rotating engineers mean you often start from scratch.

Strong

If you keep the same person, they get to know you.

Strong

Nobody knows your business better.

Strong

You know it better than anyone, even if the IT is a mystery.

Businesses that do not run on Microsoft
Weak

If you run on Google Workspace or are Mac-only, a generalist will serve you better, and we will say so.

Strong

Generalists support whatever you use.

Strong

Most platforms are covered.

Partly

Depends on the individual.

Partly

Depends on the person you hire.

Partly

Depends on your own knowledge.

Large or multi-site organisations
Partly

Built for small and medium-sized businesses rather than organisations with hundreds of users across many sites.

Partly

Varies with the size of the firm.

Strong

Built for scale, with national coverage.

Weak

One person cannot cover several sites.

Partly

You will soon need a team, not a person.

Weak

Not realistic beyond a handful of people.

Contract flexibility
Partly

12-month minimum term, because Microsoft sells Business Premium on an annual commitment. After that, 30 days’ notice.

Partly

Typically 12 to 36 months.

Weak

Multi-year contracts are common.

Strong

Pay as you go, with no tie-in.

Partly

Employment contracts and notice periods apply.

Strong

Nothing to sign.

Training and consultancy from the same people
Strong

Vantage 365 Training and Vantage 365 Consultancy are part of the same group, so training and bigger projects come from people who already know your setup.

Weak

Formal Microsoft training is rarely offered.

Partly

Often available, as separate projects with separate teams.

Weak

Rarely offered.

Weak

They may be the one who needs the training.

Weak

You would need to find it yourself.

Select any rating to see the reason behind it. Ratings describe each type of provider in general, not any named company. Scroll sideways on smaller screens.

The short version

Which option fits you

Vantage 365 Support

You run on Microsoft 365, are a small or medium-sized business, and want one price that includes the licence, with specialists who know your setup.

A local generalist

You run a mix of platforms, or you are not on Microsoft at all, and want a nearby team for everything.

A national provider

You have hundreds of users across many sites, or you genuinely need 24/7 cover.

A freelancer

You have a few people, simple needs, and can live with waiting when they are busy.

An in-house hire

You are large enough to need someone in the building every day. Many businesses pair an in-house person with managed support.

Doing it yourself

You are very small, comfortable with technology, and your time is cheaper than a support contract.

Straight answers

Questions about choosing IT support

Is managed IT support better than an in-house IT person?

For most small businesses, yes. One in-house person costs a full salary, can't cover every part of Microsoft 365 in depth, and leaves you without IT when they're on holiday or off sick. Managed support gives you a team for a fixed monthly price. Once you're large enough to need someone in the building every day, the best answer is often both: an in-house person working alongside managed support.

When is a local generalist IT company a better choice than Vantage 365 Support?

When your business doesn't mainly run on Microsoft, for example if you use Google Workspace or are Mac-only, or when you want the cheapest possible seat price. Our specialism is Microsoft 365, and that's where we add the most value. If it isn't where your business runs, a generalist will serve you better, and we'll say so.

Does Vantage 365 Support offer 24/7 IT support?

No. Our helpdesk runs Monday to Friday, 8am to 6pm, and we review security alerts every working day. Most businesses of our clients' size don't need round-the-clock cover. If yours genuinely does, we'll tell you and help you find a provider that offers it.

Is a freelance IT contractor cheaper than managed IT support?

In a quiet month, often yes. The difference shows when something goes wrong: a freelancer may be on another job, there's no cover when they're away, and the total depends on how many hours you need. Managed support costs the same every month, with a team behind it, and includes the security and backup work that keeps problems from happening.

Can we keep our in-house IT person and use managed support as well?

Yes. This is called co-managed IT support. Your in-house person keeps day-to-day ownership, and we provide the Microsoft 365 depth, security tooling and cover for holidays and sickness that one person can't provide alone.

How much does Vantage 365 Support cost?

£79 per user per month, excluding VAT, with your Microsoft 365 Business Premium licence included. There's a 12-month minimum term, because Microsoft sells Business Premium on an annual commitment, and 30 days' notice after that.

Not sure which you need?

Start with a free health check

We review your Microsoft 365 security and licence spend and tell you what we find. If managed support is not the right option for you, we will say so.